The leaflet

I created this blog to give references for the leaflet "Cock-a-doodle-DON'T" - The sad story of our humble hens. 
I hope it clarifies any uncertainties, or at least lets you know what kind of sources were consulted for the claims in the leaflet. 
You will note many of the referenced documents are available online if you wish to check.  Others, including journal articles, may be available online if you do a search on the publication title.  Otherwise they will probably be in a well-stocked library such as a university library.  I did my non-online research at the Biological Sciences Library of the University of Queensland, St Lucia, which allows non-students to look at their collection - so it should all be available there.

Click on the pictures below to see larger versions.









Photos

All farm photos were taken on Australian farms by Animal Liberation Victoria. These photos and more can be found at http://www.openrescue.org/archives.html.

The chicken slaughter photo is indicative of the process in Australia.

Egg laying hens

Egg-laying hens


Australian law allows farmers to keep a hen in a space smaller than an A4 sheet of paper for her entire life (1).

Egg farms producing “cage eggs” are huge sheds keeping tens of thousands of birds in row upon row of such tiny cages.

Hens can become immobilised in the bars and die of asphyxiation or dehydration (2).

Decomposing corpses are often found in cages with live birds (2).

Through selection, lighting and feed (detailed in 1) hens are forced to produce an egg almost every day (3).

Stress can make caged birds peck each other.  To combat this, part of their beak is cut off with hot blades. Research from within the industry gives a second reason to beak trim: to make them eat less (egg production being unaffected). Beak trimming cuts through nerves causing on-going pain, as well as impairing a hen’s ability to pick up food - considered an economic bonus for the farmer (4),(5),(6).

The life span of a commercial egg producing hen - whether cage, barn or free range – is approximately 18 months as opposed to 10–12 years in natural conditions - she is killed when her egg production declines (3).

The slaughter process for hens in all systems of egg production is the same as for meat chickens. (7)

*Extra information: often her bones will break in the process of being caught, put in cages, transport, and slaughter. This is because they are so weak, from laying so many eggs and lack of exercise. Eggs require large amounts of calcium for the shells which may be diverted from the bird's own bones, and caged birds in particular move very little so get no weight-bearing exercise to strengthen bones. (8),(9),(10).

Parent birds of chicks for all systems including free-range, are kept in crowded sunless sheds. (11),(12)

For all egg production methods including free-range, male chicks are killed by gassing or mincing alive (11)
(they neither lay eggs nor grow quickly enough for meat).




References:



(1) "Model Code of Practice for the Welfare of Animals – Domestic Poultry 4th Edition" (2002) by Standing Committee on Agriculture and Resource Management (SCARM). Source: http://www.publish.csiro.au/books/download.cfm?ID=3451




(2) Evidence from numerous farms visited by animal liberationists, as detailed at http://www.openrescue.org/.




(3) National Farmers Federation (1997) “Australian Agriculture (6th ed)” Morescope, Hawthorn East.

This books explains hens are kept in a brooding area for about 1 month after hatching, then put in cages and they start laying at about 5 months. They lay 21-22 dozen eggs in the first year after being put in cages, and produce for 12-14 months, and are slaughtered at about 80 weeks old.

This is a highly unnatural egg production rate induced by human intervention. Birds usually only lay eggs to reproduce. They lay an egg a day for a few days in a row, two or three times a year (varies between species).

For information about how many eggs in a typical bird’s clutch: http://www.birds.cornell.edu/AllAboutBirds/studying/understanding/clutch/document_view

Time between clutches has been reduced to about 1 day in domestic hens, so they lay eggs almost every day for humans to eat.

From: Bellairs R & Osmond M (c2005) “Atlas of Chick Development 2ed” San Diego: Elsevier Academic Press. Preview of this book, including the part with this information (page 3), available from http://books.google.com.au/

Producing an egg takes a lot of energy and nutrients from a hen’s body so laying one everyday places unnatural strain on hens.




(4) Glatz P (2000) "Review of beak trimming methods" Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation (RIRDC) Publication 00/72. Source: http://www.rirdc.gov.au/reports/CME/00-72.pdf

Excerpt: "in order for beak-trimming to be performed only once, the savings in labour and other costs associated with the second beak-trim must be greater than the costs associated with the increased feed intake. Beak-trimming twice, significantly reduces feed intake."

This document also says it is common practice in Australia to cut the beak twice for each hen, once before about 10 days old, and once again at about 10-14 weeks.

Elsewhere in the document it says egg production doesn't decrease with decreased food intake.




(5) Glatz P (1990) "Effect of age of beak-trimming on the production performance of hens" Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture, vol 30 (349-355)

Excerpt: "Layers not trimmed consumed significantly more food, laid fewer eggs and had poorer food efficiency than beak trimmed birds. Early in lay there was no difference in daily egg production with age at beak trimming, but by 50 weeks of age, birds trimmed at hatching or 42 days were producing more eggs than those trimmed at 10 days of age. Chickens trimmed at hatching consumed less food than chickens trimmed at 10 days, and in the late laying phase (67-82 weeks) all beak trimmed groups had significantly lower food intake than control hens. These results show that age of beak trimming influences performance and that considerable saving in food costs for the Australian Poultry Industry can be achieved by trimming half of the top beak and one third of the bottom beak of chickens at hatching."

"During the experiment trimmed chickens ate less food than the control hens. This large difference in food consumption between trimmed and control hens could be due to pain, reduced food wastage and poorer feather cover. Pain is a factor thought to reduce feed intake of beak trimmed hens. Breward and Gentle (1985) have suggested that neuromas formed in the stump of trimmed beaks and exhibiting abnormal spontaneous nerve discharges might indicate long-term pain. If there is persistence of pain in the beak, then pecking at drinking nipples and water troughs might be just as painful as feeding. Reduction of water intake could result in reduced food intake. On the other hand, the top of the beak contains mechanoreceptors (Gentle and Breward 1986) which, when removed, impair the mechanical ability of the hen's beak for picking up food immediately after trimming and later during lay (Gentle et al. 1982)."




(6) Glatz P (1987) "Effects of beak trimming and restraint on heart rate, food intake, body weight and egg production in hens" British Poultry Science, vol 28 (601-611)




(7) "Model Code of Practice for the Welfare of Animals – Livestock at Slaughtering Establishments" (2002) by Standing Committee on Agriculture and Resource Management (SCARM). Source: http://www.publish.csiro.au/books/download.cfm?ID=2975




(8) "Model Code of Practice for the Welfare of Animals – Land Transport of Poultry 2ed" (2006) by Primary Industries Standing Committee (PISC).
Source: http://www.publish.csiro.au/books/download.cfm?ID=5391




(9) Gregory N & Wilkins L (1989) "Broken bones in domestic fowl: handling and processing damage in end-of-lay battery hens" British Poultry Science, vol 30 (555-562)




(10) Gregory N et al (1990) "Broken bones in domestic fowls: effect of husbandry system and stunning method in end-of-lay hens" British Poultry Science, vol 31 (59-69)




(11) "Model Code of Practice for the Welfare of Animals – Domestic Poultry 4ed " (2002) by Standing Committee on Agriculture and Resource Management (SCARM). Source: http://www.publish.csiro.au/books/download.cfm?ID=3451




(12) Australian Certified Organic Standard (2006). http://www.australianorganic.com.au/_files/AOS%202006%2001.03.06%20FINAL_low%20res%20no%20graphics.pdf

The Standard does not apply to the parents of organically-reared birds. Organic producers buy their hens as chicks from the same farms supplying the battery cage system, and no improved welfare standards apply to the parents.
 

Meat Chickens

Reared for meat


Virtually all chickens raised for meat in Australia are factory farmed. (1)

The birds are crowded into sheds, by law up to about 20 full-grown birds per m2. (2)

They are left to stand in their own stinking excrement, which releases noxious gases causing them eye and respiratory damage. (3)

Through selective breeding, meat chickens are forced to grow unnaturally fast.  It once took 14 weeks for a chicken to grow to 1.6 kg, it now takes just over five weeks (4).

This unnatural growth rate leads to high rates of leg disorders (well documented by vets and the industry), leaving many birds crippled and unable to reach food or water (5),(6).

For more than one in four it found “there is likely to be chronic pain and discomfort” due to their leg trouble - some become immobile. (7)

Often their hearts can’t cope, so many die from heart attacks (8),(9),(10), even before they are 6 weeks old. Overgrown babies, this is their age when they are taken for slaughter(11).

Certified Organic Free-range meat chickens endure a marginally longer life as they are bred to grow slightly slower, reducing some of the problems plagueing the intensive system. (12a)

But like their non-organic cousins they are still caught as overgrown babies, stuffed in small crates and shipped to the same type of slaughterhouse to endure the same type of slaughter. (12b)

The automated slaughter process starts with a human quickly and roughly hanging the fully-conscious birds by the legs in moving metal shackles. Their heads are immersed in an electrified tank of water to stun them (13)

But this is not always successful. Many reach the automatic throat cutter or scalding tanks alive and are either boiled to death or drowned. (14)


References:


(1) Non-intensive systems incur higher production costs and expect higher retail prices, so will always advertise their 'free-range' status - if it isn't stated, the chicken was most certainly intensively farmed.




(2) Animal Care and Protection Regulation 2002 (Qld). Source: http://www.legislation.qld.gov.au/LEGISLTN/CURRENT/A/AnimalCaPrR02.pdf


For broilers (meat chickens), the Regulation says 40kg of birds is allowed per square metre, which is about 20 full-grown birds. If you’ve ever seen an adult hen, you will know they’re not that small, and 20 in a square metre is very crowded. Similarly, for egg layers, the less-than-an-A4 page allows very little movement, and only with difficulty.

Also: "Model Code of Practice for the Welfare of Animals – Domestic Poultry 4th Edition" (2002) by Standing Committee on Agriculture and Resource Management (SCARM). Source: http://www.publish.csiro.au/books/download.cfm?ID=3451



(3) Carpenter G et al (1986) "Effect of internal air filtration on the performance of broilers and the aerial concentrations of dust and bacteria" British Poultry Science, vol 27 (471-480)



(4) Hartmann W (1989) "From Mendel to multi-national in poultry breeding" World's Poultry Science Journal, vol 45 (5-26)




(5) Dansbury T et al (2000) "Self-selection of the analgesic drug carprofen by lame broiler chickens" Veterinary Record, vol 146 (307-311)



(6) Bains B (1994) "Broilers suffer from dyschodroplasia and femoral necrosis" Misset World Poultry, vol 10:10 (109-111)



(7) Kestin S et al (1992) "Prevalence of leg weakness in broiler chickens and its relationship with genotype" Veterinary Record, vol 131 (190-194)

This study found 90% of meat chickens had a gait (walking) abnormality of some degree.

The study also says “In addition, some of the birds had probably died of malnutrition or dehydration before they could be (studied).”



(8) Steele P & Edgar J (1982) "Importance of acute death syndrome in mortalities in broiler chicken flocks" Australian Veterinary Journal, vol 58 (63-66)



(9) Riddell C & Springer R (1984) "An epizootiological study of acute death syndrome and leg weakness in broiler chickens in Western Canada" Avian Diseases, vol 29 (90-102)



(10) Olkowski A & Classen H (1997) "Malignant ventricular dysrhythmia in broiler chickens dying of sudden death syndrome" Veterinary Record, vol 140 (177-179)



(11) Many citations, e.g.

Berndtson E, Danielsson-Tham M & Engvall A (1996) “Campylobacter incidence on a chicken farm and the spread of Camphylobacter during the slaughter process” International Journal of Food Microbiology, vol 32:1-2 (35-47)

(Cites 5-6 weeks rearing time in this study)

Puette M, Crowell W & Hafner W (1994) “Ultrastructural examination and cell count determinations of avian glomeruli from grossly normal and grossly swollen kidneys of broilers at slaughter” Avian Diseases, vol 38:3 (515-522)

(Cites 6-7 weeks at slaughter in this study)
 
 
 
(12) Australian Certified Organic Standard (2006). http://www.australianorganic.com.au/_files/AOS%202006%2001.03.06%20FINAL_low%20res%20no%20graphics.pdf
(a) From the Standard: "As a guide, meat chicken species should be grown to a minimum age of 70 days."

(b) There are no special guidelines listed for slaughter of free-range chickens. While abattoirs have to be organic certified and meet organic standards in terms of keeping organic animals away from non-organic, etc, these abattoirs also slaughter non-organic animals. One can therefore expect the same type of slaughter.



(13) "Model Code of Practice for the Welfare of Animals – Livestock at Slaughtering Establishments" (2002) by Standing Committee on Agriculture and Resource Management (SCARM).

Source: http://www.publish.csiro.au/books/download.cfm?ID=2975



(14) Stevenson P (2001) "Animal Welfare Problems in UK Slaughterhouses" Compassion in World Farming Trust (CIWF). Source: http://ciwf.org.uk/publications/reports/animal_welfare_problems_in_uk_slaughterhouses_2001.pdf
While this is a UK report, poultry slaughter is virtually the same in either country so similar problems would be expected.